
That's Not My Kitten! by Fiona Watt and Rachel Wells. Ages 0-3. DONE
That's Not My Teddy! by Fiona Watt and Rachel Wells. Ages 0-3. DONE
Usborne books knows how to do things right. These are two touchy/feely cardboard books with simple text and pictures with texture.
Watt lists the ways that different animals have different traits (long ears/short ears; soft tail/curly tail) to find the right animal.